One New Follower

Content warning (spoiler): stalking
Originally published in WATCH: A Stalking Anthology by Black Hare Press

โ€œTruth or dare?โ€ Kendra asked, her eyes sparkling mischievously in the glow of the LED light strips outlining the bedroom walls.

Emilia chewed her lip. โ€œDare,โ€ she replied.

Kendra whispered in Laceyโ€™s ear. Laceyโ€™s eyes widened. Her mouth made an O.

โ€œShould I?โ€ Kendra said.

Lacey nodded. โ€œDefinitely.โ€

โ€œShould you what?โ€ Emiliaโ€™s eyes darted between her two friends.

โ€œOkay, hereโ€™s the dare,โ€ Kendra said. โ€œWhoever your next follower is, you have to pretend to be in love with him.โ€

โ€œNo matter how gross he is,โ€ Lacey added.

โ€œYou guys โ€ฆโ€ Emiliaโ€™s mouth fell open in disbelief. โ€œSeriously? Pretend for how long?โ€

โ€œUntil he loves you back.โ€

Emilia groaned. She had over a million followers on Instagram. Many of them were men twice her age, who left creepy comments and flooded her DMs with futile requests for nudes. Some even offered cash.

โ€œYouโ€™re an โ€˜influencer,โ€™โ€ Lacey said, making air quotes. โ€œSo, influence.โ€

Suddenly, Emiliaโ€™s iPhone pinged with a new follower notification. Before she could look at it, Lacey snatched the device away.

โ€œHey! Give it โ€“โ€ Emilia tried to grab the phone, but Lacey tossed it to Kendra.

โ€œLetโ€™s see โ€ฆโ€ Kendra tapped the notification, then burst out laughing. โ€œOh my God, you guys.โ€ She held out the phone for the others to see. On the screen was a photo of a round-faced man with a neck beard, wearing a GameStop uniform.

โ€œEmilia, meet your new boyfriend.โ€ She glanced at the screen. โ€œJason Jerkins, aka starwarsgeek98.โ€

โ€œHis name is Jerkins?โ€ Emilia fell backward on the bed, feigning death. โ€œFucking kill me.โ€

Kendra dropped the phone on Emiliaโ€™s stomach. โ€œDM him.โ€

โ€œNow?โ€ Emilia complained. โ€œFine.โ€ She unlocked her phone and tapped out a few words, followed by the whoop sound of a sent message. Then she locked the phone and slammed it face-down on the bed. โ€œI hate you.โ€

โ€œWe hate you, too,โ€ Kendra said sweetly.

โ€œSo much,โ€ Lacey agreed.

โ€œBye, bitches!โ€ Emilia called from the front door.

Kendra stuck out her tongue and waved, then climbed into her Lexus.

Lacey sat in the passenger seat. โ€œYou think itโ€™ll work?โ€ she whispered as she blew Emilia a kiss.

โ€œLetโ€™s go find out.โ€

Kendra parked her car in front of the GameStop. A man with a round face and a neck beard leaned down and waved through the glass.

Kendra grimaced at Lacey with a pained expression, then lowered the window and smiled sweetly. โ€œHey, Jason.โ€

โ€œIt worked!โ€ the man exclaimed. He was practically hyperventilating with excitement. โ€œShe messaged me!โ€

โ€œTold you,โ€ Kendra said. She pointed at the pair of envelopes in his hand. โ€œThose for us?โ€

โ€œSure are.โ€

The man passed the envelopes to Kendra. She handed one to Lacey, then poked her thumb into the other and ruffled through the thick stack of twenty-dollar bills inside.

โ€œYou really think I have a chance?โ€ he asked hopefully.

โ€œDefinitely,โ€ Kendra nodded. โ€œWord of advice though? She likes to play hard to get, so whatever you do โ€ฆ donโ€™t give up.โ€

โ€œDonโ€™t worry,โ€ the man said. โ€œI wonโ€™t.โ€


Looking for more? Check out all the free stories, drabbles, and podcasts. And be sure to follow @warrenbenedetto on Twitter, Instagram, and Bluesky


Get new stories and updates via email.